View in browser
cipher-logo

DECEMBER 14, 2022

 

Hello! Welcome to the last edition of 2022. Thank you for reading Cipher in our first full year! 

 

Today, we’re reflecting on this year’s energy trends. Our next edition on January 4 will look ahead at the trends we’re watching for 2023.

 

Listen up: I’m joining the Energy Gang airing this Friday wherever you get your podcasts.

 

Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up here.

 

Send your energy photos, story tips and more to news@ciphernews.com.

6c1fc624-18f3-4cc6-b453-db9c17e6ed94

HARDER LINE COLUMN

War and new climate law make history in 2022

 

BY: AMY HARDER

Every year since 2018, I’ve looked back and ahead at the trends shaping the past year and the year to come, including reality checks of my previous predictions. We’re keeping the tradition going.

     

This week let’s look back on the trends we predicted would drive 2022. Then, our Jan. 4 edition will look at the trends we’re watching at Cipher in 2023.

     

Before we get to the five trends we wrote about last January, there’s a big one we didn’t foresee: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February.

 

The resulting and ongoing war has severely exacerbated the energy crisis, which we mentioned as a 2021 trend. The war is permeating virtually every geopolitical debate and is changing the course of history.

 

In the short-term, the conflict is prompting a rush to secure natural-gas supplies outside of Russia and a resurgence of coal power, particularly within Europe. Longer term, though, it’s hastening the move away from fossil fuels, according to two separate reports from the International Energy Agency in recent months (its annual outlook in October and its renewable energy forecast earlier this month).

 

Unlike during previous energy crises, many kinds of clean energy are now at a point in their development and affordability where they could realistically replace oil, natural gas and coal.

 

Our five predicted trends for 2022:

 

More money, but hopefully not more problems.

 

This time last year, I said the U.S. Bipartisan Infrastructure Law’s climate and energy funding, which at the time was a record $115 billion, could create headaches for implementation.

 

The Inflation Reduction Act, whose total funding going toward climate is $369 billion over 10 years, dwarfs all prior investments in this space.

 

So, I was right about there being more money—but I’m blown away by how much!

 

The challenges implementing IRA will be similarly supercharged.

 

Potential issues include hiring enough workers to implement the law quickly enough so companies can take advantage of the law’s time-sensitive incentives. Next year, the law and its proponents will also face Republican scrutiny with the GOP in control of the House of Representatives.

 

First-of-their-kind projects to the starting line.

 

I might want to reconsider including this as a trend in the future—unless I want to list it as a trend every year for the next 30 years!

 

We are seeing a lot of projects—too many to name here—be announced, break ground or commence construction.

 

A smattering of examples: Lower-carbon hydrogen plants all around the world, including Texas, the Netherlands and the United Arab Emirates; and at least two sustainable aviation fuel plants, including Fulcrum BioEnergy plant in Nevada and LanzaJet’s plant in Georgia that received the first grant from the Catalyst program at Breakthrough Energy (which I mentioned in my 2022 look-ahead piece). Georgia is also fast becoming ground zero for electric-vehicle manufacturing.

 

Back in January, I mentioned the U.S. State Department’s First Movers Coalition, a group of companies launched in November 2021 supporting cleantech products in eight hard-to-abate sectors, like aviation and manufacturing.

 

At the annual United Nations Climate Conference of the Parties (known as COP27) in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt in November, FMC announced it’s tackling cement too. At next year’s COP28 in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, the group will launch an effort tackling the chemicals sector, a spokesperson said.

 

Global climate and energy equity.

 

Progress on this topic has been a mixed bag.

 

Climate-fueled extreme weather—especially when afflicting low-income nations—received top billing at COP27. World leaders agreed to create the first loss and damage fund wherein wealthy countries pay developing countries to recover from extreme weather events.

 

While the announcement shows increasing awareness of the effects of climate change, such a fund does not replace the financing developing countries need to continuously adapt to future warming impacts, leaders from developing countries and experts say, as Anca wrote recently.

 

In my predictions, I wrote I would be looking to see if financial and multilateral institutions from wealthier nations would show leniency on previously announced restrictions on fossil-fuel financing in developing countries.

 

That seems unlikely from at least one powerful source: the European Investment Bank, according to a September report in The Financial Times.

 

Despite the restrictions for developing countries like those in Africa, Europe is increasingly turning to African natural gas to make up for its loss of Russian resources.

 

Such a twist of circumstances provides an ironic backdrop for African leaders to emphasize the importance of developing their economies with natural gas, as Nigeria’s president said in a November Washington Post op-ed and a top United Nations official explained in a Cipher Newsmakers video interview from September.

 

Whether the VC market cools down.

 

Venture capital is still pouring into climate technologies, but at a cooler rate than in 2021.

c02308bb-9aee-4b08-8188-b95572a655f9

Source: PitchBook • Data compiled upon request from Cipher. *2022 data complete through Dec. 5.

 

“I think some of these sectors got a little overheated and ahead of themselves,” said Eric Toone, the technical investment lead at Breakthrough Energy Ventures, one of the world’s biggest funders of climate tech startups. “The market overall has cooled off a little bit, which is not necessarily a bad thing.”

Toone specifically mentioned the food space, including lower carbon protein companies, such as Beyond Meat, whose stock price is down nearly 80% over the past year.

 

Despite these challenges, stocks of climate-minded companies are, on average, doing better compared to the broader stock market, according to a stock index tracking roughly 40 companies in this space created by Energy Impact Partners, a VC firm focused on climate tech.

09a7a46a-dea7-4c17-9a42-303e648511d0

Source: Energy Impact Partners • The EIP Climate Tech Index tracks the performance of public companies primarily involved in providing technology that supports global decarbonization. Companies included can be found at the source link.

 

Reckoning with clean-energy criticism.

 

In my 2022 look-ahead, I highlighted four areas of strife I saw emerging in the clean energy debate:

  • Appropriately disposing of cleantech at the end of its life;

  • Safely mining for clean energy materials;

  • Streamlining permitting processes;

  • Ensuring new cleantech industrial facilities (like direct air capture) are built with environmental justice in mind.

Calls to streamline permitting came to a political head this fall (on the heels of a two-part Cipher series on the topic). But nothing has passed Congress and progress seems unlikely any time soon.

 

Movement on these topics is usually slow. The war in Ukraine and resulting energy crisis demanded attention that might have otherwise gone to these other areas.

 

What’s next: In our Jan. 4 edition, we’ll be highlighting five trends Cipher will watch next year. What’s on your radar? Tell us at news@ciphernews.com.

 

Editor’s note: Breakthrough Energy Ventures (BEV) is a venture capital fund within the Breakthrough Energy network, which also supports Cipher. Catalyst is a program within Breakthrough, which is also a partner with the First Movers Coalition. Bill Gates, founder of Breakthrough Energy, has provided funding to Beyond Meat.

Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
4ac2c647-2ed2-4082-bad8-ae29dfee3666

Lunchtime Reads and Hot Takes

What you need to know about the U.S. fusion energy breakthrough — The Washington Post

Amy’s take: A good summary that isn’t too technical or long, with compelling quotes like this one from Dennis Whyte, director of the Plasma Science and Fusion Center at MIT: “Once you’ve got scientific viability, you’ve got to figure out engineering viability.” Put simply, you have to walk before you run, and we’ve learned to walk, so now we can learn to run.

 

Fusion breakthrough thrills physicists, but won’t power your home soon — Canary Media

Amy’s take: Most fusion startups are working on a different method than Tuesday's breakthrough.

 

Can Fusion Solve the Climate Crisis? — The New York Times

Amy’s take: Tackling climate change is such a slow-moving process that it allows for seemingly contradictory positions to be simultaneously accurate: Yes, this is a big deal. No, it won’t power our homes soon. But, no, that doesn’t mean we should stop. Patience people! This is a “yes, and” problem.

 

Fusion energy breakthrough by US scientists boosts clean power hopes — Financial Times (paywall)

Amy’s take: Kudos to the FT for breaking this news.

 

Liebreich: The Unbearable Lightness of Hydrogen — BloombergNEF

Amy’s take: Moving hydrogen around sounds tiring—and expensive.


A 100MW solar farm in Texas will mount panels directly on the ground — Canary Media

Amy’s take: This is important in that it allows for more solar on less land and on more types of land.

Wyoming nuclear plant delayed, tentative start date pushed to 2030 — Billings (Montana) Gazette (paywall)
Amy's take: While we emphasized projects getting off the ground in our main article, others will take longer, as TerraPower is learning. This is an unfortunate but not surprising turn of events considering a Russia-owned company was the sole provider of the fuel, as we wrote earlier this year. 

 

Green Hydrogen Gets a Boost in the U.S. With $4 Billion Plant — The Wall Street Journal

Amy’s take: The new subsidies from IRA still don’t entirely wipe out the green premium of renewable hydrogen.

 

This Lab-Grown Meat Startup Is Cutting Straight to the Steak — Bloomberg

Amy’s take: A bioprinter that prints steaks!?

 

NY project will use high-tech sensors to get more clean energy onto grid — Canary Media

Amy’s take: One problem is utilities make money building new lines, not making existing lines more efficient.

 

Carbon Removal Is Coming to Fossil Fuel Country. Can It Bring Jobs and Climate Action? — Inside Climate News

Amy’s take: Long and worthy read. One landowner said they turned down money to put solar panels on their land despite saying they would have been “set for life.”

 

These Home Appliances Are Using Power Even When Turned Off — Bloomberg

Amy’s take: But what about the cat?! Also, 3am called, it wants its energy checked.

 

Carbon capture for New York high-rise apartments is a real thing now — Canary Media

Amy’s take: This move addresses an overlooked challenge—how to retrofit existing buildings to tackle climate change.

For a sweltering petrostate, a ‘carbon neutral’ World Cup is a challenge — The Washington Post

Amy’s take: I’d love to see an opposite story on what city would be an ideal World Cup host, considering its weather, host capacity, climate efforts, etc., and then what drawbacks arise?

More of what we're reading: 

  • EU strikes deal on world-first carbon border tariff — Reuters

  • Lithium-ion batteries see first-ever price increase — E&E News (paywall)

  • Kerry expects ‘very tricky’ year for climate fundraising — The Washington Post

  • Study Explores the Geographic Implications of Carbon Taxes — Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago

  • A giant clean-energy transmission line to New York City is now underway — Canary Media

Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
 

AND FINALLY...

Beef-free lunch

b882fd4c-185e-47c2-8180-92eaa22c7599

My lunch companion over the weekend enjoyed her first-ever Beyond Meat burger. We were dining at RÜT, a vegan restaurant in Spokane, WA. I opted for the veggie chili, but I did enjoy some of those sweet potato fries.

 

Each week, we feature a photo that is somehow related to energy, the thing we all need but don’t notice until it’s expensive or gone. Email your ideas and photos to news@ciphernews.com.

Twitter
LinkedIn
Facebook
 

Editor’s note: In addition to supporting Cipher, Breakthrough Energy also supports and partners with a range of entities working to tackle climate change, including nonprofits, corporations, startups and research firms. For more information on Cipher’s editorial policy, click here.

cipher-logo-footer

You received this email because you signed-up for newsletters from Cipher.
Change your preferences or Unsubscribe here.

Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up now to get Cipher in your inbox.

 

Cipher by Cipher by Breakthrough Energy
PO Box 563 
Kirkland, WA  98033
United States

 

FOLLOW US:

twitter-icon
linkedIn-icon
youtube-icon